Commentary blogger and journalist James Kirchick has engaged The Nation in some spirited debate over the years, most recently taking on our publication of Sean Penn’s essay about Raul Castro. Normally we welcome the argument. Today, though, we had to ask ourselves if he’s running out of worthy targets. Kirchick attacked The Nation’s Act Now blog and Associate Publisher Peter Rothberg for a post yesterday suggesting legendary singer Pete Seeger be considered for a Nobel Peace Price. The idea of Seeger taking home a Nobel didn’t sit well with Kirchick, who launched an extensive harangue against Seeger’s past associations, affiliations and communist leanings:
One can understand how the folks over at the Nation would consider membership in the Communist Party … “the best kind of patriotism,” given that publication’s role in trying to redefine “patriotism” so as to include knee-jerk anti-Americanism and support for illiberal thugs and tyrants spanning the past century and up to the present day. Genuine patriotism, however, the kind felt by non-Nation-reading Americans, infers nothing more complicated than a love of one’s country and its fundamental values of liberty and individual rights, something that’s hard to glean in the pages of the Nation.
We thought about a full-throated response to Kirchick. After all, the “knee-jerk anti-Americanism” practiced by The Nation in recent years includes such radical endeavors as winning benefits for veterans wrongly denied medical care; exposing misuse of U.S. military funds in Iraq; demanding enforcement of the Voting Rights Act; and advocating in the Act Now blog for keeping toxins out of children’s toys. Kirchick certainly could have made his point about Seeger without deploying outmoded and unoriginal criticisms of The Nation and our readers, few of which hold true today.
The best criticism, though, may come from one of his own commenters, one of whom wonders why Kirchick is “fixated on fighting 40-year old battles.” We’re a little surprised that Kirchick didn’t have anything more pressing to write about. We hope you’ll weigh in as well, either in the comments at our original Act Now post about Seeger or over at Commentary.